Known as the Linear Pottery culture (or LBK, after their German name, Linearbandkeramik), these early agriculturalists were direct descendants of the people who began to domesticate plants and animals in the hills of Anatolia around 9000 B.C.E. By 5500 B.C.E., they had reached today’s Hungary. Then they spread westward, farther into Europe. The LBK farmers flourished for more than 400 years, eventually occupying a 1500-kilometer belt of fertile land stretching as far west as the Paris Basin.
Then something went terribly wrong. Vráble and other mass graves across Europe attest to a wave of brutality around 5000 B.C.E., about the same time as hundreds of LBK settlements across the continent abruptly vanished. In the aftermath, parts of the continent remained empty for centuries. Other settlements transitioned peacefully into something else, with people living in the same place and continuing to farm, but building houses and decorating their ceramics in a different way. “The LBK were the first farmers, the first large pan-European culture, and the first time we see these repeated finds of violence,” says Christian Meyer, an independent osteoarchaeologist who has studied human remains from multiple LBK mass graves.
The finds at Vráble and other LBK sites challenge a long-held notion that prehistory was more or less peaceful, with isolated cases of interpersonal violence but no large-scale conflicts or wars. It may also shed light on one of prehistory’s great vanishing acts. “It’s one of the most interesting questions in history,” Fuchs says. “What led to the disappearance of an entire culture?”
(...) But as more burials emerged, those easy explanations faded. If conflict was a regular part of LBK life, the graves should appear throughout the culture’s 400-year span instead of only at the very end. And each new LBK massacre site seems to have its own distinct character and particular details that suggest some mysterious constellation of brutal practices, not competition for land or mates. “What we see is different from anything we see before. It’s an indication of an end phase, where people turn to rituals and odd beliefs,” says Leibniz Center for Archaeology archaeologist Detlef Gronenborn. “Then it breaks out in an orgy of violence. Then it stops, but it’s too late.”
(...) Why did violence break out all across the LBK at the same time, and with such lasting consequences? Since the discovery of the Talheim Death Pit, archaeologists have been searching for a convincing explanation. “Are these strange manipulations a reaction to a crisis,” Zeeb-Lanz asks, “or an effort not to let a crisis happen?”
Archaeologists often invoke overpopulation and climate change to explain ancient turmoil. But so far, none of the bones from massacre sites have shown evidence of famine or malnutrition. And even if there was a shift in the region’s climate, “I’m hesitant to point to climate change as a single driver,” says Rick Schulting, an archaeologist at the University of Oxford. “There are all kind of cases where the climate changes and people do not start killing each other in large numbers.”
To him the evidence points to “something of a cultural collapse.” From a demographic point of view, the LBK was a stunning success story. What started as a small core group of pioneering farmers spread and expanded across vast territories in just a few centuries, a population boom with few parallels in human history. But perhaps that growth was unsustainable.
“As LBK people multiply, communication becomes more and more difficult, and society breaks apart,” Gronenborn says.
Zeeb-Lanz thinks sites like Herxheim were ways to reinforce cultural connections in an increasingly unfamiliar world, perhaps through human sacrifices or some other Stone Age bonding rites. “We’re looking at a change in ideology over a generation or two. Social ideas and cohesion aren’t working well,” Zeeb-Lanz says. “And ritualistic violence is a very strong way to bring cohesion in a community.”
Penny Bickle, an archaeologist at the University of York, suggests a culture accustomed to constant expansion might have simply run out of room. Around 5100 B.C.E., the furious pace of the LBK’s territorial expansion slows, then stops, as it reaches the edges of the fertile loess zone. “Maybe the society reaches the limits of the landscape where expansion makes sense. Moving on and making new settlements doesn’t work as a social system anymore, so they start to look inwards,” Bickle says. “There’s a shift in how people are relating to each other.”
Whatever its cause, the LBK’s end has forced archaeologists to grapple with the fact that human beings have always had the capacity to brutalize others. “It’s a basic human thing,” Meyer says. “If there are problems, people try to find a scapegoat.”
Yet Schulting warns against ignoring the centuries when the LBK was a peaceful, flourishing culture, or the many settlements that transitioned into a different way of life without obvious signs of bloodshed. “Vráble and these other sites show violence is always in the repertoire of human behavior. But that doesn’t mean it’s inevitable.”

